{"task":{"id":"697f4f1bbe12","name":"旅行垂类 Phase 1 · 5 case 7 维度评测","description":"Phase 1 旅行垂类双层架构验证 (5 case · v11 新版)\n\n看视频后每 case 打 7 维度分 (1-5 星):\n- 画质 · 转场流畅度 · BGM 贴合度 · 选片质量 · 章节切分 · 整片节奏 · 整体观感\n\nT3 套路符合度 (旅行: 山河大片/慢游手记/地标打卡/亲友同游 章节 pattern 是否合理) 在文字框里说.\n其他想说的 = 自由发挥.\n\n5 case landmark 识别 + chapter pattern 分配:\n- A 旅行+人 · landmark=None\n- D 风光 · landmark=None\n- F 大群体 · landmark=None\n- L 福建土楼 · landmark=福建土楼·承启楼 high\n- M 徽州古城 · landmark=徽州古城 high","type":"open","created_at":"2026-05-21 22:47:50","status":"active","questions":"[{\"key\": \"q_quality\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"画质 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=严重模糊 / 3=跟手机原图差不多 / 5=原图级清晰\"}, {\"key\": \"q_transition\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"转场流畅度 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=硬cut跳像PPT / 3=默认1s fade不出彩 / 5=转场跟BGM beat对齐\"}, {\"key\": \"q_bgm\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"BGM 贴合度 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=完全错配 / 3=调性匹配但平淡 / 5=BGM让画面意境上一档\"}, {\"key\": \"q_selection\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"选片质量 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=多张废片或精品被删 / 3=没明显废片 / 5=像有摄影师精挑\"}, {\"key\": \"q_chapter\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"章节切分 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=章节名跟内容不符 / 3=边界对但名平淡 / 5=章节名有叙事张力\"}, {\"key\": \"q_pacing\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"整片节奏 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=太快或太慢 / 3=平铺直叙 / 5=节奏跟BGM对应\"}, {\"key\": \"q_overall\", \"type\": \"rating\", \"label\": \"整体观感 (1-5)\", \"placeholder\": \"1=看完想关掉 / 3=默认模板水平 / 5=主动转发让人感动\"}, {\"key\": \"q_t3\", \"type\": \"textarea\", \"rows\": 2, \"label\": \"套路符合度 (旅行)\", \"placeholder\": \"章节 pattern 选择对吗?山河大片/慢游手记/地标打卡/亲友同游 安排合理?不符的话哪儿不符\"}]"},"items":[{"id":"aa3ba64da856","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","label":"A · 18ph 旅行+人 (主体72%)","media_type":"video","media_url":"https://test.colorv.chat/uploads/travel_phase1_2026-05-20__A_18ph_旅行+人.mp4","pair_id":"","sort_order":0,"description":"18 photos · 旅行+人 · main_theme=旅行 · landmark=None"},{"id":"2a061ee811f1","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","label":"D · 10ph 风光 (主体0%)","media_type":"video","media_url":"https://test.colorv.chat/uploads/travel_phase1_2026-05-20__D_10ph_风光.mp4","pair_id":"","sort_order":1,"description":"10 photos · 高山峡谷风光 · main_theme=旅行 · landmark=None"},{"id":"c34c0a42fc62","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","label":"F · 19ph 大群体 (主体84%)","media_type":"video","media_url":"https://test.colorv.chat/uploads/travel_phase1_2026-05-20__F_19ph_大群体.mp4","pair_id":"","sort_order":2,"description":"19 photos · 大群体赏牡丹 · main_theme=旅行 · landmark=None"},{"id":"18d032334784","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","label":"L · 76ph 福建土楼","media_type":"video","media_url":"https://test.colorv.chat/uploads/travel_phase1_2026-05-20__L_76ph_福建土楼.mp4","pair_id":"","sort_order":3,"description":"76 photos · 多 POI · main_theme=旅行 · landmark=福建土楼·承启楼 (high)"},{"id":"748cebea4b24","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","label":"M · 65ph 徽州古城","media_type":"video","media_url":"https://test.colorv.chat/uploads/travel_phase1_2026-05-20__M_65ph_徽州古城.mp4","pair_id":"","sort_order":4,"description":"65 photos · main_theme=旅行 · landmark=徽州古城 (high) · 慢游手记候选"}],"responses":[{"id":"3d67a2a50845","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","item_id":"aa3ba64da856","pair_id":"","evaluator":"DD","score":null,"preferred_item_id":"","comment":"说实话看不出来章节切分，这个片子就是一个图片变成视频相册，中规中矩。节奏上没啥问题。整体来说也没有亮点。就是普通。\r\n目前整体效果可能不如用模版，因为模版还有一些花样，装饰元素，转场效果之类的，简单来说就是通过模版里的各种小特效来提升观感。目前这个片子整体就比较平淡。但平淡其实不是导演层的问题吧，毕竟内容相对就是比较平。直观看，这一版本的效果不如套现有的模版，因为视觉上不够华丽。","answers":{"q_quality":"5","q_transition":"4","q_bgm":"4","q_selection":"4","q_chapter":"3","q_pacing":"4","q_overall":"3","q_t3":"没有不符"},"created_at":"2026-05-26 14:33:58"},{"id":"511db85e2db4","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","item_id":"2a061ee811f1","pair_id":"","evaluator":"DD","score":null,"preferred_item_id":"","comment":"目前看不出来章节切分和选片，主要是因为我也看不到原始素材有哪些，看不出来哪些选了，哪些没选。然后就是这个片尾的质感，好像音乐戛然而止了，感觉体验一般。BGM里倒是有些跟“高山”相匹配的元素，但总体感觉还是不太搭配。","answers":{"q_quality":"5","q_transition":"4","q_bgm":"3","q_selection":"4","q_chapter":"3","q_pacing":"4","q_overall":"4","q_t3":"山河大片，整体符合，BGM比较壮阔，符合主题"},"created_at":"2026-05-26 14:33:58"},{"id":"80a598261eb6","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","item_id":"c34c0a42fc62","pair_id":"","evaluator":"DD","score":null,"preferred_item_id":"","comment":"BGM不太符合，大花轿这个主题是哥哥和妹妹，爱情向。片子内容是朋友春游赏花，影响观感。","answers":{"q_quality":"3","q_transition":"4","q_bgm":"1","q_selection":"3","q_chapter":"3","q_pacing":"4","q_overall":"3","q_t3":""},"created_at":"2026-05-26 14:33:58"},{"id":"d78fbf972b99","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","item_id":"18d032334784","pair_id":"","evaluator":"DD","score":null,"preferred_item_id":"","comment":"片子里部分横向的图片感觉出现了拉伸。这个片子里出现了很多的横图、竖图混排，感觉编排上应该想办法做一些优化。出现了一些博物馆展品的照片，都是竖图，一张一张展示，感觉竖图在横向视频的展示画幅太小了，这种场景里可能就需要拼多，一个画面里同时展示多张照片这种，有可能可以提升观感？横竖图混合的场景，需要一个更好的表现方法。","answers":{"q_quality":"4","q_transition":"4","q_bgm":"4","q_selection":"3","q_chapter":"3","q_pacing":"4","q_overall":"4","q_t3":"符合"},"created_at":"2026-05-26 14:33:58"},{"id":"ab9b739188fa","task_id":"697f4f1bbe12","item_id":"748cebea4b24","pair_id":"","evaluator":"DD","score":null,"preferred_item_id":"","comment":"中规中矩，没啥亮点，也没啥显著问题","answers":{"q_quality":"4","q_transition":"4","q_bgm":"3","q_selection":"3","q_chapter":"3","q_pacing":"4","q_overall":"3","q_t3":""},"created_at":"2026-05-26 14:33:58"}]}